Driving licence checks from the age of 65: Transport study quantifies the socioeconomic costs of compulsory health checks
As the population ages, the number of older people actively participating in road traffic is rising. In the public and political debate on road safety, the issue of compulsory health checks for older drivers is a recurring topic of discussion. A recent study by transport economists uses a model for Germany to examine the consequences of age-based health checks from a holistic perspective, whilst also taking social impacts into account.
To this end, the researchers modelled a procedure as practised in various European countries: from the age of 65, drivers would be required to undergo a compulsory medical check-up with their GP every five years. The estimated cost per check-up is 25 euros. The model calculations show that, if such health checks were introduced in Germany, around three per cent of people aged over 65 would permanently lose their driving licence in the long term. This corresponds to around 540,000 people.
More than just the cost of the check-up
However, an socio-economic cost-benefit analysis goes far beyond the immediate expenditure on the tests. It makes it possible to compare different societal impacts by expressing them in monetary terms. These include, for example, avoided accident damage and savings on vehicle costs, but also the consequences of a driving ban: the loss of personal independence, restricted social participation and the risk of psychological strain due to increasing isolation. “Only when all these different effects are considered together can we evaluate whether a measure is actually beneficial from a societal perspective,” explains Tano Kannegiesser, research assistant at the Chair of Economics, esp. Transport Policy and Spatial Economics and lead author of the study.
Accident risk as a key factor
Whether the overall outcome is positive or negative depends significantly on one factor in the calculations: by how much does the average accident risk fall amongst older drivers who pass the test and are allowed to continue driving? While accidents do, in purely mathematical terms, decrease simply because people without a driving licence no longer drive – the actual aim of the checks is to specifically identify and filter out particularly unsafe drivers.
According to the model calculations, the average accident risk among the remaining older drivers would need to fall by just under two per cent for the safety gains to offset the significant losses in mobility. However, no such safety gains have been demonstrated in previous scientific studies for Europe.
Without any gain in safety, the harm to society outweighs the benefits
If this additional safety benefit does not occur, the negative consequences clearly outweigh the benefits: in their model calculation, the researchers estimate the cost to society at around 15,000 euros per driving licence permanently revoked. Extrapolated to the German population – with approximately 50,000 driving licences revoked annually – this results in economic costs of around 760 million euros per year.
The researchers therefore warn against a blanket adoption of European practice: “Germany should only introduce age-based medical tests based on the European model if their effectiveness can be clearly demonstrated. The measures should be specifically tailored to actual individual risks and, in addition to potential safety benefits, should also take into account the consequences for mobility and social participation,” demands Kannegiesser.
The study “Cost-Benefit Analysis of age-based screening for driving licence renewal” by Tano Kannegiesser and Dr Stefan Tscharaktschiew has been published in the journal Transport Policy.
Content
M.Sc. Tano Kannegiesser
"Germany should only introduce age-based medical tests based on the European model if their effectiveness can be clearly demonstrated. The measures should be specifically tailored to actual individual risks and, in addition to potential safety benefits, should also take into account the consequences for mobility and social participation."